QodeAssist/docs/agent-templates-design.md

Agent Templates — Design Note (body model, include, extends)

Status: agreed design / ready to implement. Dev-facing (not end-user docs). Scope: how agent TOML profiles describe the request and share structure.

Problem this replaces

The shipped model has each agent embed a [template].message_format jinja string that hand-builds the whole request body as text, plus [template.sampling] and [template.thinking.*] blocks merged in by applySampling. Pains:

• Massive copy-paste: 9 OpenAI-compatible agents share a byte-identical ~50-line message_format; 4 Claude agents share another; role + README context are identical across 18 files.
• [template.sampling] / [template.thinking.overrides] / [template.thinking.request_block.*] describe merge machinery, not the request body — they don't look like the actual API call. The overrides vs request_block split is meaningless (both are deep-merged into the request identically).
• Manual JSON-by-string-concatenation: trailing-comma bookkeeping ({% if not loop.is_last %},{% endif %}) everywhere; a missing comma fails silently at runtime (renderBody returns nullopt, only a qWarning).
• include is hard-disabled, so there is no way to share a sub-fragment.

Agreed model

1. [body] is a deep-mergeable table = the request body, 1:1 with the API

Replace the message_format string and the sampling/thinking blocks with a single [body] TOML table whose keys are the literal request-body fields. Because it is a table (not a string), extends / deepMerge can override it field-by-field — variants become a 2-line delta instead of a copied body.

Field-value rules at build time (per key in [body], applied recursively):

• string containing jinja ({{ or {%) → render through inja, splice the output as raw JSON (array / object / string). Empty render → key omitted.
• string without jinja (e.g. "high") → literal JSON string, as-is.
• number / bool / inline-table → as-is.

So messages / contents and system / system_instruction are just string fields holding jinja; everything else (max_tokens, temperature, stream, thinking, output_config, generationConfig, …) is a literal value that reads exactly like the curl body.

No runtime toggles: thinking / tools / streaming are fixed per agent. A thinking agent literally carries the thinking fields; a non-thinking variant is a separate file. There is no {% if thinking %} in the body. system uses {% if existsIn(ctx, "system_prompt") %} only because that is about presence of data, not a mode toggle. enable_thinking / enable_tools are capability hints (used for UI badges and to decide tool-definition injection) — the body is the source of truth for what is actually sent, so a thinking agent's body must carry the thinking fields regardless of the flag.

Outside the body:

• model — the TOML model is the default; a per-agent override chosen in QodeAssist settings wins. Overrides are stored in agent_models.json (agentName → model) and applied by AgentFactory when it builds the agent (AgentFactory::effectiveModel/setModelOverride); Session still seeds the payload model from the resolved cfg.model. URL-model providers (Google) put a ${MODEL} placeholder in endpoint; Session substitutes the resolved model into the endpoint before sending (same substitution style as ${PROJECT_DIR}/${HOME}), so the override drives the URL too.
• tools — injected by the provider when enable_tools is set (tool definitions are dynamic, from ToolsManager; they can't be authored in TOML).
• stream — always on. Literal "stream": true in the body for OpenAI / Claude / Mistral / Responses / Ollama; encoded in the endpoint URL for Google.

2. include re-enabled as whitelisted partials

The message-array rendering (the complex, comma-heavy part) lives in sources/agents/partials/*.jinja, shared via {% include %}. The throwing include callback is replaced by a sandboxed resolver that:

• rejects names containing .., a leading /, or a scheme/drive;
• resolves only against known roots: bundled :/agents/partials/ then the user partials/ dir;
• parses/caches the partial in the same inja::Environment.

A missing/typo'd partial is a load-time error.

3. extends shares config down a hierarchy

extends already exists (resolveExtends + deepMerge + abstract/hidden); it keeps doing what it does, now over the structured [body] too. A flat 2 levels — each provider base sets system_prompt = """{{ agent_role("developer") }}""" (the role text comes from the role JSON via the agent_role callback; see below). No shared root base:

openai_base (abstract)     → system_prompt + provider/endpoint/enable_tools + [body]
  ├─ openai_chat           → name
  ├─ mistral_chat          → name, provider, endpoint
  └─ mistral_reasoning     → + enable_thinking
anthropic_base (abstract)  → system_prompt + provider/endpoint + [body]
  ├─ claude_chat           → name
  └─ claude_sonnet         → + [body] thinking / output_config
google_base (abstract)     → system_prompt + provider + [body]
  └─ gemini_chat           → endpoint (${MODEL}) + [body.generationConfig] thinkingConfig

Notes:

• [body] is shared whole when identical (the 8 OpenAI-compatible providers); a variant overrides only the differing field — no duplicated body.
• Arrays (tags) are replaced on override, not appended (deepMerge recurses objects only). A child that wants base tags + extras restates the full list.
• Division of labour: include shares the message-rendering fragment across unrelated families; extends shares config (system_prompt / endpoint / body) down one inheritance chain.
• With model gone, per-model files collapse: agents that previously differed only by model become one agent (the client picks the model). A separate file is only needed when the body genuinely differs (effort, no-thinking, …).

System prompt — a composable template with building blocks

The old role (static text) and context (jinja) layers collapse into one agent.system layer in Session, rendered through ContextRenderer. The agent's system_prompt field IS that template, and the user edits it (in the profile) to compose the prompt from building-block callbacks:

• {{ agent_role("<id>") }} — insert a role's text (Developer/Reviewer/Researcher…). Implemented as a ContextRenderer callback (registerAgentRole) that reads userResourcePath("qodeassist/agent_roles/<id>.json")["systemPrompt"]. Returns "" if missing. Lives in sources/agents (no dependency on settings/), so it works in the plugin and bench. The role text lives once in the role JSON (managed by the settings Roles UI); the chat bases just carry system_prompt = """{{ agent_role("developer") }}""".
• {{ read_file("...") }} / file_exists / ${PROJECT_DIR} / ${HOME} — existing ContextRenderer helpers, composable in the same template.

So a profile can do system_prompt = """{{ agent_role("developer") }}\n\n{{ read_file("…") }}""". qodeassist.cpp calls AgentRolesManager::ensureDefaultRoles() at startup so the default role JSONs exist before agents load. There is NO per-agent settings override — the edit point is the profile's system_prompt. Code-completion/FIM agents set no system_prompt.

Worked examples

OpenAI base:

abstract = true
system_prompt = """{{ agent_role("developer") }}"""
provider_instance = "OpenAI (Chat Completions)"
endpoint = "/chat/completions"
enable_tools = true

[body]
max_tokens  = 8192
temperature = 0.7
stream      = true
messages    = """
[ {% include "partials/openai_messages.jinja" %} ]
"""

Mistral reasoning child (delta only):

extends = "OpenAI Base Chat"
name    = "Mistral Reasoning Chat"
provider_instance = "Mistral AI"
endpoint = "/v1/chat/completions"
enable_thinking = true

[body]
reasoning_effort = "medium"

Claude base (literally the curl body):

abstract = true
system_prompt = """{{ agent_role("developer") }}"""
provider_instance = "Claude"
endpoint = "/v1/messages"
enable_thinking = true
enable_tools = true

[body]
max_tokens  = 16000
temperature = 1
stream      = true
thinking      = { type = "adaptive", display = "summarized" }
output_config = { effort = "high" }
system   = """{% if existsIn(ctx, "system_prompt") %}{{ tojson(ctx.system_prompt) }}{% endif %}"""
messages = """
[ {% include "partials/anthropic_messages.jinja" %} ]
"""

Sonnet child (delta only):

extends = "Anthropic Base Chat"
name    = "Claude Sonnet"

[body.output_config]
effort = "medium"

Google base (${MODEL} in endpoint; streaming in the URL):

abstract = true
system_prompt = """{{ agent_role("developer") }}"""
provider_instance = "Google AI"
endpoint = "/models/${MODEL}:streamGenerateContent?alt=sse"
enable_thinking = true
enable_tools = true

[body]
system_instruction = """{% if existsIn(ctx, "system_prompt") %}{ "parts": [ { "text": {{ tojson(ctx.system_prompt) }} } ] }{% endif %}"""
contents = """
[ {% include "partials/google_contents.jinja" %} ]
"""

[body.generationConfig]
maxOutputTokens = 16000
temperature     = 1
thinkingConfig  = { includeThoughts = true, thinkingBudget = 8192 }

Partials

partials/openai_messages.jinja dispatches per message:

{% if existsIn(ctx, "system_prompt") %}
{ "role": "system", "content": {{ tojson(ctx.system_prompt) }} },
{% endif %}
{% for msg in ctx.history %}
  {% if msg.role == "assistant" %}{% include "partials/openai_assistant.jinja" %}
  {% else if length(filter_by_type(msg.content_blocks, "tool_result")) > 0 %}{% include "partials/openai_tool_results.jinja" %}
  {% else %}{% include "partials/openai_user.jinja" %}
  {% endif %}
{% endfor %}

partials/openai_assistant.jinja:

{% set tcalls = filter_by_type(msg.content_blocks, "tool_use") %}
{
  "role": "assistant",
  "content": {{ tojson(msg.content) }}
  {% if length(tcalls) > 0 %}
  , "tool_calls": [
    {% for b in tcalls %}
    { "id": {{ tojson(b.id) }}, "type": "function",
      "function": { "name": {{ tojson(b.name) }}, "arguments": {{ tojson(tojson(b.input)) }} } },
    {% endfor %}
  ]
  {% endif %}
},

partials/openai_tool_results.jinja:

{% for b in filter_by_type(msg.content_blocks, "tool_result") %}
{ "role": "tool", "tool_call_id": {{ tojson(b.tool_use_id) }}, "content": {{ tojson(b.content) }} },
{% endfor %}

partials/openai_user.jinja:

{% if existsIn(msg, "images") %}
{ "role": "user", "content": {% include "partials/openai_image_content.jinja" %} },
{% else %}
{ "role": "user", "content": {{ tojson(msg.content) }} },
{% endif %}

partials/openai_image_content.jinja:

[
  { "type": "text", "text": {{ tojson(msg.content) }} }
  {% for img in msg.images %}
  ,
  {% if img.is_url %}
  { "type": "image_url", "image_url": { "url": {{ tojson(img.data) }} } }
  {% else %}
  { "type": "image_url", "image_url": { "url": "data:{{ img.media_type }};base64,{{ img.data }}" } }
  {% endif %}
  {% endfor %}
]

partials/anthropic_messages.jinja:

{% for msg in ctx.history %}
{
  "role": {{ tojson(msg.role) }},
  "content": [
    {% for b in msg.content_blocks %}
      {% if b.type == "image" %}{% include "partials/anthropic_image.jinja" %}
      {% else %}{{ tojson(b) }},
      {% endif %}
    {% endfor %}
  ]
},
{% endfor %}

partials/anthropic_image.jinja:

{
  "type": "image",
  "source":
  {% if b.is_url %}
  { "type": "url", "url": {{ tojson(b.data) }} }
  {% else %}
  { "type": "base64", "media_type": {{ tojson(b.media_type) }}, "data": {{ tojson(b.data) }} }
  {% endif %}
},

partials/google_contents.jinja:

{% for msg in ctx.history %}
{
  "role": {% if msg.role == "assistant" %}"model"{% else %}"user"{% endif %},
  "parts": [ {% for b in msg.content_blocks %}{% include "partials/google_part.jinja" %}{% endfor %} ]
},
{% endfor %}

partials/google_part.jinja:

{% if b.type == "text" %}
{ "text": {{ tojson(b.text) }} },
{% else if b.type == "thinking" %}
{ "text": {{ tojson(b.thinking) }}, "thought": true, "thoughtSignature": {{ tojson(b.signature) }} },
{% else if b.type == "tool_use" %}
{ "functionCall": { "name": {{ tojson(b.name) }}, "args": {{ tojson(b.input) }} } },
{% else if b.type == "tool_result" %}
{ "functionResponse": { "name": {{ tojson(b.name) }}, "response": { "result": {{ tojson(b.content) }} } } },
{% else if b.type == "image" %}
  {% if b.is_url %}
  { "file_data": { "mime_type": {{ tojson(b.media_type) }}, "file_uri": {{ tojson(b.data) }} } },
  {% else %}
  { "inline_data": { "mime_type": {{ tojson(b.media_type) }}, "data": {{ tojson(b.data) }} } },
  {% endif %}
{% else %}
{ "text": "" },
{% endif %}

C++ work

In JsonPromptTemplate:

• Parse [body] as a QJsonObject (not a string). Walk it recursively and build the request: render jinja-bearing string values via inja and splice the parsed JSON; pass literal strings / scalars / inline-tables through; drop keys whose render is empty.
• Delete m_sampling, m_thinking, and applySampling entirely — the body is the request; there is no separate sampling/thinking merge.
• Drop the thinkingEnabled parameter from buildFullRequest / Provider::prepareRequest / Session — it no longer affects rendering.
• Add a JSON-aware trailing-comma stripper before QJsonDocument::fromJson (tracks string/escape state so ,} / ,] inside string values are not touched). This is what lets partials emit an unconditional , after every element and drop all loop.is_last bookkeeping.

In AgentConfig / AgentLoader:

• Replace messageFormat (string) with body (QJsonObject); merge role + context into system_prompt. [template].sampling / [template].thinking are removed.
• extends / deepMerge are unchanged; they now also merge [body].
• Validate at load: a referenced partial must resolve; the assembled body must parse as JSON (render once against a synthetic context with tool_use / tool_result / image). Catches breakage at startup, not mid-conversation.

Model selection (per-agent override):

• AgentFactory owns an agentName → model map loaded from agent_models.json (loadModelOverrides/saveModelOverrides). create()/createFromFile() apply the override into the built AgentConfig; effectiveModel() exposes the resolved value; setModelOverride() persists. The settings UI (AgentDetailPane) edits it via an editable Model field; list/roster widgets display effectiveModel.
• Session substitutes ${MODEL} in cfg.endpoint with the resolved model before sendRequest (covers Google, whose model lives in the URL), and still seeds the payload model from cfg.model. The provider keeps injecting tools when enable_tools is set.

In Session:

• Collapse the agent.role + agent.context system-prompt layers into one rendered system_prompt layer.

Implementation order

1. JSON-aware trailing-comma stripper + whitelisted include resolver (enables readable partials).
2. [body]-table model in JsonPromptTemplate + loader; delete sampling/thinking/applySampling; drop thinkingEnabled.
3. system_prompt merge in loader + Session.
4. Per-agent model override in AgentFactory (agent_models.json) + ${MODEL} endpoint substitution in Session; editable Model field in settings; convert bundled agents to the base/partials/extends layout.
5. Load-time validation (partial resolves, body parses).